by John Lauer
An independently designed 12 V to 5 V, 1 A synchronous buck molecule (TI TPS54202), with calculations, ngspice and PSpice simulation, KiCad 10 schematic and board, and the board laid out and analysed with adom-aiflow.
5b68870
TPS54202: fitted ngspice model vs TI's PSpice model
Both models use the same external parts and load steps as sim/transient.py: VIN 12 V, L 15 uH / 118 mOhm, COUT 36.3 uF effective, Rtop 73.6 k, Rbot 10 k, Cff 68 pF, EN 1 M / 150 k, a 1 A load stepped to 0.5 A at 7 ms and back to 1 A at 8 ms. TI's model is TPS54202_TRANS.LIB (package SLVMBJ5), run with STEADY_STATE=0 in PSpice for TI. Both are measured with the same code.
| metric (12 V, 1 A) | fitted ngspice model | TI model |
|---|---|---|
| VOUT mean at 1 A | 4.9797 V | 5.0088 V |
| VOUT ripple (peak to peak) | 3.19 mV | 5.0 mV (1 mV output quantisation) |
| inductor ripple (peak to peak) | 0.396 A | 0.407 A |
| peak inductor current at startup | 1.226 A | 1.226 A |
| time to 95 % VOUT | 4.757 ms | 4.838 ms |
| overshoot, 1 A to 0.5 A | 79.6 mV | 93.2 mV |
| undershoot, 0.5 A to 1 A | 78.4 mV | 90.7 mV |
| settling to 1 % after the step up | 202.6 us | 171.9 us |
Startup and the inductor current match to within about 2 %. The fitted loop under-predicts the load-step deviation by about 15 %. VOUT is about 30 mV higher in TI's model, which regulates FB to about 0.599 V where the fitted model uses the 0.596 V reference.
Design conclusion
For this internally compensated part, the datasheet's crossover estimate (equation 14, fo = 3.95 / (VOUT x COUT)) makes fo x COUT a constant, so the load-step deviation is about dI x VOUT / (2 pi x 3.95), independent of COUT: about 0.2 V for a full 1 A step. TI's 0.5 A steps (93 and 91 mV) scale to about 185 mV (3.7 %) for 1 A.
More output capacitance would lower the crossover and leave the deviation about the same. Only a larger Cff would help, and Cff stays at 68 pF to keep the crossover under the datasheet's 40 kHz limit. 3.7 % is inside the usual +/-5 % window for a 5 V rail, so COUT is unchanged. The next check is a real 0 to 1 A step on the bench.
# TPS54202: fitted ngspice model vs TI's PSpice model
Both models use the same external parts and load steps as `sim/transient.py`: VIN 12 V, L 15 uH / 118 mOhm, COUT 36.3 uF effective, Rtop 73.6 k, Rbot 10 k, Cff 68 pF, EN 1 M / 150 k, a 1 A load stepped to 0.5 A at 7 ms and back to 1 A at 8 ms. TI's model is `TPS54202_TRANS.LIB` (package SLVMBJ5), run with `STEADY_STATE=0` in PSpice for TI. Both are measured with the same code.
| metric (12 V, 1 A) | fitted ngspice model | TI model |
|---|---|---|
| VOUT mean at 1 A | 4.9797 V | 5.0088 V |
| VOUT ripple (peak to peak) | 3.19 mV | 5.0 mV (1 mV output quantisation) |
| inductor ripple (peak to peak) | 0.396 A | 0.407 A |
| peak inductor current at startup | 1.226 A | 1.226 A |
| time to 95 % VOUT | 4.757 ms | 4.838 ms |
| overshoot, 1 A to 0.5 A | 79.6 mV | 93.2 mV |
| undershoot, 0.5 A to 1 A | 78.4 mV | 90.7 mV |
| settling to 1 % after the step up | 202.6 us | 171.9 us |
Startup and the inductor current match to within about 2 %. The fitted loop under-predicts the load-step deviation by about 15 %. VOUT is about 30 mV higher in TI's model, which regulates FB to about 0.599 V where the fitted model uses the 0.596 V reference.
## Design conclusion
For this internally compensated part, the datasheet's crossover estimate (equation 14, fo = 3.95 / (VOUT x COUT)) makes fo x COUT a constant, so the load-step deviation is about dI x VOUT / (2 pi x 3.95), independent of COUT: about 0.2 V for a full 1 A step. TI's 0.5 A steps (93 and 91 mV) scale to about 185 mV (3.7 %) for 1 A.
More output capacitance would lower the crossover and leave the deviation about the same. Only a larger Cff would help, and Cff stays at 68 pF to keep the crossover under the datasheet's 40 kHz limit. 3.7 % is inside the usual +/-5 % window for a 5 V rail, so COUT is unchanged. The next check is a real 0 to 1 A step on the bench.