by John Lauer
An independently designed 12 V to 5 V, 1 A synchronous buck molecule (TI TPS54202), with calculations, ngspice and PSpice simulation, KiCad 10 schematic and board, and the board laid out and analysed with adom-aiflow.
main
John Lauer
ECAS vs MLCC: a study of moving the buck to polymer capacitors, with its section card
531f515
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111112113114115116117118119120121122123124125126127128129130131132133134135136137138139140141142143144145146147148149150151152153154155156157158159160161162163164165166167168169170171172173174175176177178179180181182183184185186187188189190191192193194195196197198199200201202203204205206207208209210211212213214215216217218219220221222223224225226227228229230231232233234235236237238239240
[
{
"variant": "A2_as_built_cff47",
"label": "As built with Cff 47 pF (the fix the measured derating calls for)",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 54.0,
"cout_eff_uF": 30.6,
"cff_pF": 47,
"fc_kHz": 30.25,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.59,
"vin_ripple_mV": 77.2,
"step_mV": 83.6,
"settle_us": 70.4,
"startup_mV": 11.4,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 17.03,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.248,
"cost": 1.534,
"tallest_mm": 5.8,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:alu47": 0.07,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"2:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"3:c100n": 0.045
},
"cap_area_mm2": 112.3
},
{
"variant": "A_as_built",
"label": "As built: 47 uF alu can + 2 x 10 uF 1206 in, 3 x 22 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 54.0,
"cout_eff_uF": 30.6,
"cff_pF": 68,
"fc_kHz": 40.46,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.76,
"vin_ripple_mV": 77.3,
"step_mV": 80.8,
"settle_us": 70.7,
"startup_mV": 11.1,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 17.03,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.248,
"cost": 1.534,
"tallest_mm": 5.8,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:alu47": 0.07,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"2:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"3:c100n": 0.045
},
"cap_area_mm2": 112.3
},
{
"variant": "B2_ecas_plus_ceramic",
"label": "ECAS + one ceramic each side: 33 uF ECAS + 10 uF 1206 in, 150 uF ECAS + 22 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 36.9,
"cout_eff_uF": 162.2,
"cff_pF": 220,
"fc_kHz": 5.87,
"vout_ripple_mV": 2.33,
"vin_ripple_mV": 105.5,
"step_mV": 58.8,
"settle_us": 104.0,
"startup_mV": 54.7,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 25.33,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.263,
"cost": 2.95,
"tallest_mm": 3.1,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.482,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.22,
"2:c100n": 0.06
},
"cap_area_mm2": 106.4
},
{
"variant": "B_ecas_swap",
"label": "ECAS swap: 33 uF ECAS + 1 x 10 uF 1206 in, 150 uF ECAS out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 36.9,
"cout_eff_uF": 152.0,
"cff_pF": 220,
"fc_kHz": 6.35,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.0,
"vin_ripple_mV": 100.9,
"step_mV": 59.7,
"settle_us": 102.0,
"startup_mV": 51.7,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 25.33,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.263,
"cost": 2.869,
"tallest_mm": 3.1,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.482,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.22,
"2:c100n": 0.06
},
"cap_area_mm2": 99.7
},
{
"variant": "C2_ecas_input_bare",
"label": "ECAS for the can, no damping resistor: 33 uF ECAS + 2 x 10 uF 1206 in, 3 x 22 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 40.4,
"cout_eff_uF": 30.6,
"cff_pF": 68,
"fc_kHz": 40.46,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.61,
"vin_ripple_mV": 75.3,
"step_mV": 80.7,
"settle_us": 70.6,
"startup_mV": 11.5,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 25.23,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.246,
"cost": 2.331,
"tallest_mm": 2.0,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.445,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.136,
"2:x7r10_1206": 0.136,
"3:c100n": 0.042
},
"cap_area_mm2": 88.0
},
{
"variant": "C_ecas_input_damped",
"label": "ECAS where it earns it: 33 uF ECAS + 0.22 ohm in place of the can, 2 x 10 uF 1206 in, 3 x 22 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 40.4,
"cout_eff_uF": 30.6,
"cff_pF": 68,
"fc_kHz": 40.46,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.65,
"vin_ripple_mV": 76.4,
"step_mV": 81.0,
"settle_us": 70.7,
"startup_mV": 11.1,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 18.48,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.201,
"cost": 2.341,
"tallest_mm": 2.0,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.09,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.248,
"2:x7r10_1206": 0.248,
"3:c100n": 0.044
},
"cap_area_mm2": 92.3
},
{
"variant": "D_dense_mlcc",
"label": "Denser MLCC only: can + 2 x 22 uF/25 V 0805 in, 2 x 47 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 55.0,
"cout_eff_uF": 29.1,
"cff_pF": 68,
"fc_kHz": 46.15,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.7,
"vin_ripple_mV": 75.0,
"step_mV": 81.1,
"settle_us": 70.6,
"startup_mV": 10.4,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 17.21,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.244,
"cost": 1.041,
"tallest_mm": 5.8,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:alu47": 0.063,
"1:x5r22_25_0805": 0.252,
"2:x5r22_25_0805": 0.252,
"3:c100n": 0.034
},
"cap_area_mm2": 97.8
},
{
"variant": "E_poscap_out",
"label": "Polymer tantalum out: as-built input, 100 uF POSCAP + 22 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 54.0,
"cout_eff_uF": 110.2,
"cff_pF": 220,
"fc_kHz": 10.75,
"vout_ripple_mV": 7.73,
"vin_ripple_mV": 80.8,
"step_mV": 63.3,
"settle_us": 100.3,
"startup_mV": 38.7,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 17.03,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.248,
"cost": 1.954,
"tallest_mm": 5.8,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:alu47": 0.07,
"1:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"2:x7r10_1206": 0.251,
"3:c100n": 0.045
},
"cap_area_mm2": 115.2
},
{
"variant": "F2_recommended",
"label": "Recommended: 33 uF ECAS + 0.22 ohm for the can, 2 x 22 uF/25 V 0805 in, 2 x 47 uF 0805 out, Cff 47 pF",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 41.3,
"cout_eff_uF": 29.1,
"cff_pF": 47,
"fc_kHz": 32.55,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.75,
"vin_ripple_mV": 74.8,
"step_mV": 84.0,
"settle_us": 68.7,
"startup_mV": 11.0,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 18.6,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.199,
"cost": 1.848,
"tallest_mm": 2.0,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.08,
"1:x5r22_25_0805": 0.25,
"2:x5r22_25_0805": 0.25,
"3:c100n": 0.033
},
"cap_area_mm2": 77.8
},
{
"variant": "F_smallest",
"label": "Smallest set: 33 uF ECAS + 0.22 ohm for the can, 2 x 22 uF/25 V 0805 in, 2 x 47 uF 0805 out",
"cin_eff_uF_12V": 41.3,
"cout_eff_uF": 29.1,
"cff_pF": 68,
"fc_kHz": 46.15,
"vout_ripple_mV": 3.83,
"vin_ripple_mV": 72.4,
"step_mV": 81.4,
"settle_us": 70.6,
"startup_mV": 10.5,
"hotplug_16V_1uH": 18.6,
"zs_peak_ohm": 0.199,
"cost": 1.848,
"tallest_mm": 2.0,
"input_cap_rms_A": {
"0:ecas33_25": 0.08,
"1:x5r22_25_0805": 0.25,
"2:x5r22_25_0805": 0.25,
"3:c100n": 0.033
},
"cap_area_mm2": 77.8
}
]