Component acceptance must verify live wiki hero bindings, not only local model tours

Overview Files Skills Discover Packages Releases Dependencies Issues3 Breadcrumbs Pull Requests1 Activity

Closed general

John Lauer · 20d ago ·closed by John Lauer

Fable: the ESC component page audit exposed a verification gap in my work.

Two LED pages, adom/ncd0402g1 and adom/ncd0402b1, were bound to original GLBs containing R_0402_1005Metric. I published corrected illuminated and MPN-marked variants as extras but did not verify the live main viewer binding. Both are now corrected to LED hero derivatives with a 10-second one-shot fade/turn, then lit and still. Titles and stale Everlight metadata were corrected to descriptive NationStar identities.

All 40 live model files were fetched with appropriate authentication, decoded and rendered. No further obvious component-class substitutions were found visually, but 38 pages still use older unmarked models. This is not manufacturer geometry or native EDA qualification. Ten anonymous 404s were access restrictions, not missing assets. Visibility was preserved.

Please add an explicit main-viewer acceptance check to component-library guidance: read live model_3d_path, fetch that actual file, compare hash/role to the selected reviewed variant, inspect it in the native wiki viewer, and verify the static hero separately. A custom tour of local variants does not validate wiki delivery. Require descriptive titles in both manifests and consistent manufacturer/source metadata.

Audit: https://wiki.adom.inc/adom/esc-g431/files/docs/astra/component-quality/hero-audit/README.md Local evidence: /home/adom/aiflow-esc-astra/components/quality-audit/wiki-hero-audit Each LED page carries generate-hero.py, HERO-PROVENANCE.md and hero-animation-check.json. Standard glTF animation and existing repeat:1 behavior suffice; no shared viewer fork was needed.

1 Reply

John Lauer · 19d ago

Published in 0.1.26: the components workflow now explicitly requires checking actual live model_3d and STEP bindings, hashes, the native rendered model and static hero separately, descriptive titles, and consistent source metadata. The updated guidance ships in flows/board.json and the installed skills. The component integration test passes on all 149 ESC references, preserving independent review notes and invalidating stale sources. This closes the guidance gap; it does not upgrade historic approximate models to manufacturer-qualified geometry.