Open bug report

Live schematic drops symbol pin identities, group headings and body fill

John Lauer · ·edited

Environment: adom-schematic local authoring candidate0.5.1 on feature/revisioned-schematic-authoring, base28df85d; WSL2/Linux, Hydrogen webview. KiCad native service10.0.2.

The live authoring preview calls kicad_self::render_inner. Its LibSym retained only geometric primitives, so it silently omitted library text (functional group headings), pin names and pin numbers. Background-filled body rectangles also rendered unfilled. The exact TMF8829 source remained complete and looked correct in native KiCad, but the webview showed a large empty body with only its central chip outline and external net labels.

Expected: preserve native chip identity and intended body fill in the live view; verify on the same source revision. Human explanatory comments must also persist as ordinary schematic text and survive native export.

A local candidate patch now retains group headings, pin names/numbers, filled bodies, and active-low overbars. It adds revisioned set_note/remove_note operations, UI controls, undo/persistence and native text export.16 authoring tests pass, including a grouped-buffer renderer regression and comment persistence/connectivity checks. Actual live repair and subsequent chip-comment edits were recorded as C64–C66 in Depth Lab. No shared release or complete cross-tool parity is claimed.

The earlier image is the faulty preview; the later image shows recovered labels/fill using the same unchanged TMF8829 symbol source (the earlier whole sheet is r79 and later r85). Remaining font/rotation/native presentation review is ongoing. Please make symbol-content parity and per-chip rationale comments part of the app’s AI hints and acceptance checks.

C61-final-r79

C64-restored-symbol

1 Reply

John Lauer ·

The reviewable local patch is attached: commit129d124 on feature/revisioned-schematic-authoring, based on28df85d.16 authoring tests pass. It adds ordinary persisted chip-purpose notes, native text export and live symbol identity/body-fill preservation, with no net-name changes. Native service validation on Depth Lab revision100 has the same128 existing ERC findings as before (126 missing project-library context,2 external power inputs). The support-chip outlines also round-trip through adom-lbr with all polyline counts retained.

This is a local development candidate, not a merged or installed shared release. The screenshots/recordings document actual browser operation; native desktop parity remains separate.

schematic-symbol-comments.patch

schematic-renderer-notes-tests.log

Log in to reply.